A bauble of thanks

When a refusal is more noble than an honour

By Terence Blacker, Friday 27 January 2012

Now and then, it is possible to catch a glimpse of how the British establishment works. These moments are rare and fleeting because an unwritten code of confidentiality, of the sort shared by members of the same club, ensures that the rest of us are kept in the dark.

Sometimes the confidentiality is mysterious. Why, for example, should the Cabinet Office be so determined to treat as some kind of dark state secret the identity of those who years ago turned down an honour? This week, it emerged that it had taken 15 months of argument around the Freedom of Information Act for Whitehall to release the names of 277 people, all safely dead, who preferred to remain undecorated.

Having lost the battle to keep this list of refuseniks under wraps, the Cabinet Office spokesman sounded distinctly flustered. “Numbers are very small,” he said. They “represent around 2 per cent of nominations”.

What a 2 per cent, though. Reading the roll of honour-refusers, one begins to understand why those in power preferred to keep it under wraps. Generals, business luminaries and stalwarts of the civil service may benefit from a title or letters after their names, but those who are their own men and women saw that there was far more to lose than to gain. They are an odd bunch, the 277. JB Priestley, Lucian Freud, Roald Dahl, Robert Graves, FR Leavis, LS Lowry, Graham Greene, Henry Moore, Philip Larkin and CS Lewis have little in common politically or personally beyond the fact that their work is the product of uncompromising individuality.

Simply by accepting a bauble of thanks from the nation, they would be sacrificing what was best about them – their apartness. Once they became part of the national community, their voice, their eyes, their strength would be changed. They neither accepted the honour nor, in what has become a new form of boasting, told the world that they had rejected it.

One has only to think of the great and the decorated of today – Sir David Hare, Sir Elton John, Dame Helen Mirren, Sir Tim Rice, Lord Prescott, Sir Mick Jagger – to understand the problem. It is as if these people have kicked themselves upstairs, away from where the messy, interesting action is taking place. They are respected, eminent men and women, but they are reduced. Their voices are muffled by ermine. No wonder the Cabinet Office wanted to keep the list of these sensible 277 people hidden.

http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/terence-blacker/terence-blacker-when-a-refusal-is-more-noble-than-an-honour-6295279.html or http://ind.pn/zhDLc4

Photograph of J.B. Priestley, by Monire Childs.  http://www.davidchilds.co.uk/Monire/Collections/Culture/J.B-Priestley/J.B-Priestley.htm or http://bit.ly/yycKeL

Related Posts

Love requires a response Reborn on the 4th of July By Logan Mehl-Laituri, 07/04/2012  8:18 am   Today marks my sixth rebirthday. In 2006, I was baptized and became...
Whose taste it is to associate and amalgamate Francis Scott Key on trial By Jefferson Morley, Wednesday, Jul  4, 2012 06:30 AM CDT   In the final two days of U.S. v. Reuben Crandall, o...
War’s a nasty thing Anniversary of the Attack on Mers-el-Kébir Announced by Archdruid Eileen, Tuesday, 3 July 2012   And what lessons we have to learn from ...
Uneasy patriot Jackie Robinson on the 4th: The Prophet and the Flag By Michael G. Long, 07/05/2012 10:42 am   One of the quiet but powerful engines that ...
Even facts now have a point of view Thomas Jefferson, our least Christian president By Stephen Prothero, July 3 2012   During a recent trip to Washington, I took in two exhib...
Let’s be honest for a change Encountering Peace: Is my Zionist dream dead? By Gershon Baskin, 07/02/2012 21:13   I am really quite concerned. I see a great disaster ab...
Thinking like Shamir It was Zionism itself that Israel buried this week. Let it go. By Bradley Burston, Jul.03, 2012 1:36 PM   It's time to take a lesson from ...
We cannot escape history George W. Bush: Still the worst By Robert Merry, Friday, Jun 29, 2012 06:30 AM CDT   In 2003, President Bush, then two years into his te...
‘Ahlan wa sahlan fikoum!   From: Børre Ludvigsen Sent: Friday, June 29, 2012 5:31 AM Subject: Emine, Fatimah and Umm Ahmad - 'ahlan wa sahlan fikoum!   It a...
A man born long before his time Morsi is no revolutionary and not much of a nationalist. The army elite has already laid traps for him By Robert Fisk, Monday 25 June 2012   ...

Permanent link to this article: http://levantium.com/2012/01/27/a-bauble-of-thanks/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.