The seduction of good sound bites

Veteran White House reporter and columni

Helen Thomas taught me that being liked isn’t everything

By , 25 Jul 2013 14:03

 

It was supposed to be our big, bonding moment – the veteran White House correspondent and the young, plucky blogger unite on stage, join the mutual admiration club, and reassure the audience that the world is not going to sh*t.

But Helen Thomas didn’t see it that way. The world was going to sh*t and the audience gathered at the Omega Institute’s 2009 Women & Power Conference needed to know that. She wasn’t going to let a little intergenerational performance get in the way of  the truth.

She talked about the lies that led us into the Iraq War and the pale, puny stuff that was being passed off for journalism nowadays. I tried to balance the dark picture she painted with stories of young women discovering feminism through blogs and getting radicalised online.

We were speaking two different languages. Mine was hopeful, perhaps naive; I gave the audience anecdotes that I knew they would be comforted by. Hers was unapologetically blunt; she didn’t appear to care about comforting people. Even staring down her 90s, she was still writing about deeply discomforting things: ineffective national security, botched foreign policy, and White House obfuscation.

When I heard that Thomas died, I returned to this moment. At the time, I remember being proud that I had “rescued” the tone of that panel – helped people see that they need not go home utterly depressed about  the state of the world. But when I thought back about that panel this week, it was Thomas I was proud of. She didn’t give into the lure of being loved by that audience. She didn’t have much use, it seemed, for short-lived admiration built on the seduction of good sound bites. She wanted something more for us, for herself; she wanted truth. Enlightment was more important than entertainment.

Unlike so many women of her generation, Thomas prized the truth above all else, including being liked. I wish that wasn’t so radical a notion, so rare an example, but in fact, Thomas is among a small group of public intellectuals that I can point to that have shown me a way of being in the world that is less about style than it is substance.

It’s even more remarkable when you consider the era in which she was shaped. My grandmothers, born in the 1920s, around the same time Helen was, weren’t like this. They were smart, passionate women, but truth was not their friend. It was frightening, unladylike, inconvenient. The personal stuff could get you shamed; the political version was the stuff of men’s lives. Women were socialised very systematically and effectively to avoid, repress, and sidestep the truth during Thomas’ formative years.

I was born with that inconvenient instinct for truth-telling, so I became a journalist, but I also came of age at a time when journalism looked less and less like the province of truth-tellers and more and more like the province of spin-doctors. It wasn’t how dogged you could be, how unabashed about distinguishing what was real from what was myth, that predicted your success; it was how fast you could process information and come up with a half-baked opinion, how deftly you could turn a phrase, how much you could make readers love you.

These measures of success take on a particularly corrosive form when applied to women. Think fast, but take time to smile, be articulate, but never complex. Readers won’t love you if they think you’re strident, boring, ugly, or emasculating. (Case in point: I was actually asked to be on that panel with Helen because I had taken Bill O’Reilly to task on air months earlier for calling her the “wicked witch of the east”.)

In other words, if Maureen Dowd was demonstrating just how cute and clever I would need to be if I ever hoped to be read, Helen Thomas’ life offered the opposite lesson: seek the truth, kid: the rest is distraction. Being liked is overrated.

I’m not in the White House press corp, nor am I an investigative journalist in the tradition of Helen. But her legacy means something dear, something core to me all the same. She provided, and will continue to provide, a set of values that have mostly been drowned out by the blowhard boys of TV and radio and even by the listicle-lovin’, traffic-driven hipsters that seem to dominate online media these days. Her commitment to tough questions and accurate, timely copy in a time of carefully cultivated likability and ever so much focus on style, gives me the courage to be so uncool as to be earnest and so boring as to be less interested in being smart than being right.

It’s not that hope isn’t a good thing, but Helen taught me that truth is the best thing.

Courtney E Martin is a writer, speaker and social media strategist based in Brooklyn. She is the author of Do It Anyway: The New Generation of Activists and the co-founder of the Solutions Journalism Network.

 

http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2013/07/2013725122624358831.html or http://aje.me/11g9s3J

Photograph of Helen Thomas leaving the White House on October 16, 2007, by Saul Loeb (LOEB/AFP/Getty Images).  http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/20/helen-thomas-dead_n_3628151.html#slide=2719198

Related Posts

Intimately backed Afghanistan: the big lie Guardian editorial, Wednesday 1 February 2012 18.04 EST ... Joseph Goebbels said that if you tell a lie big enough and...
Years of mendacity and deceit Still Britain rattles sabres. Nothing has been learned from Afghanistan By Simon Jenkins, Thursday 2 February 2012 16.00 EST ... The Afghan w...
Old herrings An attack on Tehran would be madness. So don't rule it out By Robert Fisk, Saturday 04 February 2012 ... If Israel really attacks Iran this y...
Dysfunctional sectarian misery An attack on Iran must be stopped By Andrew Murray, Saturday 4 February 2012 09.00 EST ... The Anglo-American aggression addicts haven't kicked...
Prophetic excerpts Arendt: Born in conflict, Israel will degenerate into Sparta, and American Jews will need to back away By Philip Weiss, January 1, 2012 ... For...
Chile has Ms. Vallejo Just Don’t Call Her Che By William Moss Wilson, January 28, 2012 ... Late last month the British newspaper The Guardian asked readers to vote...
Imminent threat of extinction We've been here before – and it suits Israel that we never forget 'Nuclear Iran' By Robert Fisk, Wednesday 25 January 2012 ... Turning round ...
Dangerous transition The Arab Spring, US foreign policy, the Status-Quo Lobby and the Dream Palace of the Zionists By Issandr El Amrani, Wednesday, January 25, 2012 .....
Something faintly fascist The present stands no chance against the past By Robert Fisk, Saturday 28 January 2012 ... The Palestinians are not only, it seems, an "inven...
Bought and paid for Newt Gingrich's agenda-setting big donor By Arun Kundnani, Saturday 28 January 2012 14.18 ES ... By donating $10m to the pro-Newt Gingrich Su...

Permanent link to this article: http://levantium.com/2013/07/25/the-seduction-of-good-sound-bites/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.