Verisimilitudinous

Camels_braying_Pushkar_Camel_Festival_Pushkar_Rajasthan_India_20121118

The Old Testament’s made-up camels are a problem for Zionism

By , Thursday 13 February 2014 08.59 EST

 

There are 21 references to camels in the first books of the Bible, and now we know they are all made up.

Some of them are quite startlingly verisimilitudinous, such as the story of Abraham’s servant finding a wife for Isaac in Genesis 24: “Then the servant left, taking with him 10 of his master’s camels loaded with all kinds of good things from his master. He set out for Aram Naharaim and made his way to the town of Nahor. He made the camels kneel down near the well outside the town; it was towards evening, the time the women go out to draw water.”

But these camels are made up, all 10 of them. Two Israeli archaeozoologists have sifted through a site just north of modern Eilat looking for camel bones, which can be dated by radio carbon.

None of the domesticated camel bones they found date from earlier than around 930BC – about 1,500 years after the stories of the patriarchs in Genesis are supposed to have taken place. Whoever put the camels into the story of Abraham and Isaac might as well have improved the story of Little Red Riding Hood by having her ride up to Granny’s in an SUV.

How can you tell whether a camel skeleton is from a wild or tamed animal? You look at the leg bones, and if they are thickened this shows they have been carrying unnaturally heavy loads, so they must have been domesticated. If you have a graveyard of camels, you can also see what proportion are males, and which are preferred for human uses because they can carry more.

All these considerations make it clear that camels were not domesticated anywhere in the region before 1000BC.

Lidar Sapir-Hen and Erez Ben-Yosef, the scientists who carried out the research, point out that the domestication of camels was hugely important economically, because they made trade possible over much larger regions of the Arabian peninsula. But that is not what has provoked excitement about their claim.

Obviously it has upset fundamentalists. Everyone else has known for decades that there is even less evidence for the historical truth of the Old Testament than there is for that of the Qur’an. But the peculiarly mealy-mouthed nature of the quotes they gave the New York Times (which is not much concerned with the feelings of Christian fundamentalists) shows where the real problem is.

The history recounted in the Bible is a huge part of the mythology of modern Zionism. The idea of a promised land is based on narratives that assert with complete confidence stories that never actually happened. There are of course other ways to argue for the Zionist project, and still further arguments about the right of Israelis to live within secure boundaries now that the country exists. But although those stand logically independent of the histories invented – as far as we can tell – in Babylonian captivity during the sixth century BC, they make little emotional sense without the history. And it is emotions that drive politics.

 

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/andrewbrown/2014/feb/13/old-testament-camels-zionism-genesis or http://bit.ly/1caPtc9

Photograph of camels braying at the Pushkar Camel Festival, Pushkar, Rajasthan, India, by John Lund/Stephanie Roeser (Getty Images).  http://bingfotos.blogspot.com/2012/11/camels-braying-at-pushkar-camel.html

Related Posts

Unsayable The World War on Democracy By John Pilger, January 20, 2012 ... Lisette Talate died the other day. I remember a wiry, fiercely intelligent woma...
Protestant empire Where Exactly Is Biblical Israel? By Rachel Havrelock, 1/14/12 05:07 PM ET ... The phrase "Biblical Israel" often passes on the lips of Repub...
Must we live forever At 65, modern Israel is falling short of Zionism's most basic goal By Matt Hill, Tuesday 16 April 2013   Soon after the founding of Isra...
Get over it Judaism is not a major player in the history of humankind By Yuval Noah Harari, Jul 31, 2016   Though many Israelis are convinced that the...
Bought and paid for Newt Gingrich's agenda-setting big donor By Arun Kundnani, Saturday 28 January 2012 14.18 ES ... By donating $10m to the pro-Newt Gingrich Su...
Grovelling to Netanyahu The 'invented people' stand little chance By Robert Fisk, Saturday 14 January 2012 ... Thank goodness we don't have to hear Newt Gingrich for a...
Death via live broadcast On third anniversary of Gaza war, we will remember By Amira Hass, 03:53 02.01.12 ... On the third anniversary of the Cast Lead onslaught, we re...
Feliz Navidad 2011 Merry Christmas (or click here for your choice of alternative winter holidays) to all, from high atop the Fidel Castro observation tower, overlooking ...
Outposts forever and Palestine Never Newt Gingrich may be able to occupy Palestine, but Israel can't By Bradley Burston, 15:17 13.12.11 ... Speaker Gingrich, if you're serious abou...
An embarrassing reflection of us   By Jacques, d'Nalgar, December 13 2015   Why all the sanctimonious hand-wringing over Donald Trump’s latest bombastics?  Are we r...

Permanent link to this article: https://levantium.com/2014/02/15/verisimilitudinous/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.