Strangely drawn

The story of Jesus is the ultimate political drama

By , Saturday 24 December 2011 04.10 EST

I shouldn’t like it. Not at all. My upbringing – regular synagogue attendance, Hebrew classes twice a week, a kosher home – was meant to inoculate me against it, ensuring that I would recoil at the mere mention of the word. And yet – and here I need to lower my voice to a whisper – I am strangely drawn to the story of Jesus.

Jews don’t even like saying the name too loud. The Talmud refers to him only as “that man”. Plenty of Jews use the Yiddish name Yoshke, which sounds more unflattering than it looks on the page. Now that I think about it, I remember my grandfather preferring the word “Yoizel”, which has a slightly gentler ring to it – so maybe I picked up this habit from him.

The point is, Jews don’t go in for Jesus. So-called Messianic Jews, “Jews for Jesus”, are ostracised almost universally by other Jews. The religion founded in Jesus’s name may have been good news for Christians, but it usually spelled trouble and persecution for the Jews. So, for people like me, an interest in Jesus is a little taboo.

Not that I’m a crypto-follower or Christian-curious or anything, don’t get me wrong. I know lots of lefties bang on about how Jesus was the first socialist and all that, but that’s not the draw for me. No, what pulls me in is the Jesus story.

I wasn’t taught it in school and I didn’t read it in the gospels. My first exposure came on TV, in the form of those Jesus films they always show at Easter. I think it was the ATV movie, Jesus of Nazareth, that got me hooked (produced, incidentally, by the unmistakably Jewish  Lew Grade). But from then on I was a sucker for any telling and retelling: whether Hollywood epics, such as The Greatest Story Ever Told, musicals like Jesus Christ Superstar, or even cunning modern-day adaptations – think Godspell or Jesus of Montreal. I lapped them all up.

A psychologist would say it’s the taboo that does it. Especially if they knew that that first, childhood viewing of Jesus of Nazareth coincided – as Easter so often does – with the first night of the Jewish festival of Passover. I was watching Robert Powell get crucified when I should have been preparing the seder table. What for most people is a tale associated with Sunday school tedium carried for me the frisson of the forbidden.

But I’m afraid I don’t think that explains it. The truth is, the Jesus story is the ultimate political drama. Imagine it: a radical firebrand, whom the powerful want to silence and shut down. But the threat is not only external. He also faces a hidden challenge from within his own inner circle, a traitor in his midst …

I admit that I brace myself when I come to hear the story told again, whether through radio drama, rock opera or, say, some BBC experimental production on the streets of Manchester. I worry: will this version blame the Romans or the Jews? Of course it’s always best when Pilate, the Roman occupier who gave the order, is the bad guy; certainly better than any suggestion, coded or otherwise, that it is the Jews who should bear the weight of guilt.

I like to think Jesus himself would understand this nervousness on my part. After all, and this is remembered less often than it might be, he was Jewish too.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2011/dec/24/jesus-ultimate-political-drama or http://bit.ly/sD1tEw

Photograph:  http://uprootedpalestinians.blogspot.com/2011/10/palestinian-spring-not-yet.html

Related Posts

Outposts forever and Palestine Never Newt Gingrich may be able to occupy Palestine, but Israel can't By Bradley Burston, 15:17 13.12.11 ... Speaker Gingrich, if you're serious abou...
Rights and wrongs are rather more complex Syria's Shades of Gray By William Dalrymple, June 07, 2003   The United States has probably never been more engaged in the Middle East t...
Dona nobis pacem Peace on earth? The end of the Iraq war By Susan Brooks Thistlethwaite, 11:01 AM ET, 12/15/2011 ... “Peace on earth!” (Luke 2:14) heralded the ...
Wise to fear Was Democracy Just a Moment? By Robert D. Kaplan, Friday, December 16, 2011 ... IN the fourth century A.D. Christianity's conquest of Europe ...
Grow your own The parable of the allotments By Julian Baggini, Thursday 15 December 2011 12.53 EST ... Last week I challenged the idea that religiosity is ...
Who are we? Newt, Mitt, Bibi and Vladimir By Thomas L. Friedman, December 13, 2011 ... I have a simple motto when it comes to the Israeli-Palestinian confl...
Against all odds?   Note:  The above foolishness was seen tonight at our local Sam's Club.  The image below is of the back side of this "extraordinary ...
According to the dictionary   I place an ear on the belly of this moment I hear wailing I place it on another moment - the same! - Sinan Antoon, Iraqi poet ...
Dwindling congregations PROOFS OF GOD IN A PHOTON By Martin Redfern, Sunday 24 December 1995 ... FOR THE first time in 400 years, sensible people are saying some ver...
Enormous self-regard Newt, the Jews, and an “Invented” People By David  Remnick, December 11, 2011 ... Late last week, as part of a Republican pander-fest for the J...

Permanent link to this article: https://levantium.com/2011/12/24/strangely-drawn/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.