History is rarely gentle

Syria’s refugees remind us of the price of revolution

By , Friday 23 March 2012 07.12 EDT

Here is the truth about revolution, war, dictatorship and resistance. It is a simple truth and it is crushing: people suffer. In this powerful picture by Greek photojournalist Giorgos Moutafis a refugee family in Janoudia in north-western Syria wait for rebels to help them across the border into Turkey. In the bold rhetoric of our time, this might be described as a picture of defeat, an indictment of Bashar al-Assad’s crackdown on opposition to his rule, a call to arms for western democracies that are so much less eager to help in Syria now than they were in Libya a year ago. Perhaps it is all those things, and anything else politics wants it to be. But first, it is a human document.

Five children sit in a pool of light amid the dark, their faces patient and resilient, their confusion and fear obvious. Each has a different expression but none are smiling. One child gazes downward while the youngest-looking boy stares at the camera. The adults in the picture, knowing more, look back at the photographer as they gather close to the children. Everyone’s eyes seem to be searching, puzzling. The glow that warms their faces reveals a moment of contemplation before the next arduous stage of a journey.

Painters have known for centuries how to use nocturnal light to intensify our recognition of vulnerability. In his painting The Nativity at Night, which dates from about 1490, Geertgen tot Sint Jans shows the Madonna and child by candlelight against the dark. In this photograph, the shiny wall of the tent or canopy behind them creates a starless black night. Against this eeriness, Moutafis is able to give this family a profound dignity as the human instinct for light in the shadowed hours heightens their meditative companionship.

It seems a timeless moment. After all the hopes, anger, and bloodshed, here we are again. Refugees wait to cross a border. Lives are turned upside down. When the Arab spring began last year it was hailed around the world as if it were a new fashion. It trended. The Occupy movement was equated with it as if there were no difference between protesting in democracies and rebelling against dictatorships. The demand for democracy that has swept the Arab world is profound, but how could anyone have expected this historic convulsion to be bloodless?

This family bear witness that history is rarely gentle. Velvet revolutions are rare. If this powerful photograph looks as if it could have been taken decades ago, or painted by an Old Master, that is because the brutal violence of Syria’s regime has unleashed realities of suffering that recur whenever the humble routines of real life are invaded by big history. Look at this picture and thank the stars you live in a boring place.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/mar/23/syria-refugees-revolution-portrait or http://bit.ly/GITcyt

Photograph:  http://www.guardian.co.uk/news/gallery/2012/mar/19/1

Related Posts

The question of why Israel rubs Why do people hate Israel? (a self-test) By Bradley Burston, May.28, 2013 | 8:15 PM   Every year, the BBC World Service publishes a Countr...
We live in the earthly one An Open Letter to Elie Wiesel By Avner Inbar and Assaf Sharon, May 27, 2010   In a recent public letter to President Obama, Elie Wiesel ...
It hurts to write this sentence Behind the use of drones is a complacent belief that murdering Muslims is always justifiable By Yasmin Alibhai Brown, Sunday 28 April 2013   ...
A load of old cobblers Syria and sarin gas: US claims have a very familiar ring By Robert Fisk, Sunday 28 April 2013   Is there any way of escaping the theatre o...
Feliz Navidad 2011 Merry Christmas (or click here for your choice of alternative winter holidays) to all, from high atop the Fidel Castro observation tower, overlooking ...
Ours will be the same As the Arabs see the Jews By His Majesty King Abdullah bin Al-Hussein (1882-1951), The American Magazine November, 1947 ... I am especially del...
One name is unavoidable Page by page, Marwan Barghouti's anti-war tome walked out of prison By Joseph Dana, December 23 2011 ... Palestinians across the West Bank an...
To even raise this question I am sorry for the role I played in Fallujah By Ross Caputi, Thursday 22 December 2011 05.00 EST ... It has been seven years since the end of...
Indigènes France's shamefully forgotten allies By Robert Fisk, Saturday 31 December 2011 ... It took Indigènes to remind the French that they owed thei...
We do sleep soundly The shocking truth that killing can be so casual By Robert Fisk, Saturday 07 January 2012 ... More horror arrives in the mail. Clive Bur...

Permanent link to this article: https://levantium.com/2012/03/23/history-is-rarely-gentle/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.